Candy Warehouse

Old Time Candy - Yummy Candy, Discount Prices - Feel Like a Kid!

Cool and wacky candy from Japan

Candy Review: Butterfinger Giant

Categories: Candy,Candy Reviews,Chocolate Candy

Tags:, , , ,

Butterfinger Giant

A lot of people don’t like Butterfingers (I am kinda in the middle myself), but even if you don’t, it’s a candy bar you should appreciate for its uniqueness. Sure, it’s not as good as a 5th Avenue (before they started using mockolate), but it actually predates the Hershey version by thirteen years to be the oldest, most popular peanut butter candy bar on the market.

Over the years, Butterfingers have undergone a variety of changes. They were reinvented as Butterfinger BBs, Butterfinger Stixx, and Butterfinger Crisp (the best candy spin-off to date). Each version offered a new way of consuming the classic flavor with some twist. For those readers old enough to remember the 90s, you might even recall Bart Simpson popularizing the bar with his catchy slogan of “Nobody better lay a finger on my Butterfinger!”

Over the years, one spin off I often saw was the Butterfinger Giant tempting me from numerous candy aisles; however, I never bothered to buy one. I was actually a little confused by them, to be honest. The packing is similar to the über-large Crunch bars Nestle also produces. Since the wrapper reads “Butterfinger pieces in milk chocolate,” I was always left speculating if this was a flattened and large Butterfinger bar, like how Crunch bars are all the same taste, just varying in size, or was this a Nestle milk chocolate bar with Butterfinger pieces loaded inside?

Finally giving into the temptation because of a sale at Walgreens, I purchased one of these to find out the truth behind the Butterfinger Giant. Opening the foil, the bar exudes faint traces of peanut butter. Examining it, my hunches are confirmed; this is indeed a Nestle chocolate bar with Butterfinger pieces.

The break is firm, but not hard, with an easy snap. Upon first bite, I am transported to the realm of Butterfinger goodness, but wait… something is different here. That crunchy layer of peanut butter that gets stuck in your teeth is missing, but it still tastes like a regular Butterfinger! I am amazed by how much I am enjoying that taste and sensation.

That is until I begin to get a sense of the chocolate. The chocolate is mild and a bit waxy, almost flavorless compared to the boldness of the Butterfinger pieces, much like the original bar where the mockolate coating is more ornate than tasty. Its mundane quality really brings down the greatness of the other flavors manifesting in the bar.

Compared to the original, this baby has some nice advantages. One, it’s actually set in real chocolate: the problem with this is that Nestle’s chocolate isn’t all that appetizing to me. The second good thing about the bar is that because the Butterfinger only exists in pieces, it doesn’t overwhelm your palate. I also enjoyed how I didn’t lose any fillings with pieces getting stuck in my teeth.

I still think that the Butterfinger Crisp is the most superior of all Butterfinger products, but this is a lovely addition to the line. Had the chocolate been richer, say like an amazing Ghirardelli dark chocolate, this would be an awesomely addictive candy bar hands down. If any Nestle people are reading this, feel free to use my idea (just as long as I get a case of them as compensation).

Buy Butterfinger Giant Online:

Related Articles:

4 Responses to “Candy Review: Butterfinger Giant”

  1. 1
    LoveyDovey says:

    yummmmmmm yummmm yumm!!!!! I love Butterfingers and I love chocolate for my treat once and a while and now that they nade it all together!! OHHH!!!!!!

  2. 2
    Mrs. Sound says:

    Dammit I love BUTTERFINGER! When I eat on McDonalds and order Mcflurry usually I want butterfinger in it instead of oreo. Yummy!

  3. 3
    Beck says:

    I’m not a big fan of the Butterfinger. However I LOVE Butterfinger Crisp!!

    This Butterfinger Giant sounds a little more edible than the original. I may give it a try!

  4. 4
    TOM says:


Leave a Reply

(Please press only ONCE then wait)

What is 15 + 13 ?
Please leave these two fields as-is:
IMPORTANT! To be able to proceed, you need to solve the following simple math question.